“PRESERVED FOREVER”: THE CHILLING EVIDENCE FROM CHRISTA PIKE’S 1995 MURDER CASE STILL LOCKED INSIDE A TENNESSEE VAULT
More than 31 years after 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer was tortured and m𝑢rdєred in Knoxville, Tennessee, the physical evidence from her case remains locked away inside a government vault.
The collection includes a pink sweater bearing a shoe-print impression, a bloodstained cloth gag with strands of Slemmer’s hair still knotted in it, a small meat cleaver, matching pentagram necklaces and a black leather jacket connected to one of the most disturbing details of the crime.
These are not simply forgotten objects from an old investigation. They are pieces of evidence that helped prosecutors build the case against Christa Pike, who was convicted of Slemmer’s murder and sentenced to dєatᩚh.
Now, as Pike remains in prison following a failed exє𝔠uti☉n attempt on September 30, 2026, the decades-old evidence is receiving renewed attention.
WHY THE EVIDENCE MUST BE KEPT FOREVER
Knox County Criminal Court Clerk Mike Hammond explained that his office is required to preserve the evidence indefinitely because Pike’s case is a capital case.
In an account of the evidence reviewed by local television station WBIR, Hammond explained that the exhibits must remain in government custody even if Pike is eventually executed.
The collection is stored in a secure area inside the City County Building in downtown Knoxville.
The preservation requirement means that the physical record of the 1995 murder will not simply disappear with the passage of time.
INSIDE THE VAULT: OBJECTS THAT TELL THE STORY
Among the most recognizable items is Colleen Slemmer’s pink sweater.
The garment reportedly still bears a visible shoe-print impression on its back, a detail that offers a stark reminder of the violence surrounding her final hours.
Other clothing recovered from the scene includes a green jacket, jeans and dirty sneakers.
Investigators also preserved a cloth gag that had been forced into Slemmer’s mouth. Strands of her hair reportedly remain knotted in the fabric.
A small meat cleaver, which Pike admitted using during the attack, is also among the retained exhibits. It has remained stored in its original brown-paper packaging for decades.
The collection includes matching pentagram necklaces associated with Pike and her boyfriend, Tadaryl Shipp. Both were photographed wearing the necklaces after the murder.
Perhaps the most disturbing object is Pike’s black leather jacket.
According to the evidence described in the original investigation, Pike removed a fragment of Slemmer’s skull after the attack and kept it in the jacket pocket. The jacket was later recovered by authorities, along with the fragment.
The objects were presented as evidence during the criminal proceedings and remain part of the official record.
THE 1995 MURDER OF COLLEEN SLEMMER
Slemmer was a 19-year-old student at the Knoxville Job Corps Center when she was killed on January 12, 1995.
Pike, who was 18 at the time, and Shipp, who was 17, lured Slemmer away from the Job Corps Center to a secluded area near the University of Tennessee’s agricultural campus.
The attack involved prolonged torture and extreme violence. Investigators later recovered clothing, weapons and other physical evidence from the scene and from locations connected to the defendants.
Pike was convicted and sentenced to dєatᩚh in 1996. Shipp was also convicted and received a life sentence with the possibility of parole.
The case became one of Tennessee’s most notorious capital murder cases, with the physical evidence playing a central role in the prosecution.
THE FAILED exє𝔠uti☉n THAT BROUGHT THE CASE BACK INTO THE SPOTLIGHT
Pike, now 50, was scheduled to be executed by lєthaℓ inje𝔠ti☉n on September 30, 2026.
But the exє𝔠uti☉n did not end as planned.
She survived two doses of pentobarbital at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville. Her attorneys later described serious problems with the intravenous lines, alleging that the medication may not have entered her bloodstream properly and instead accumulated in her arms.
Pike was hospitalized in ᑕriᩚtiᩚcal condition and spent several days unconscious before regaining consciousness. She was subsequently returned to prison.
The Tennessee Supreme Court’s order dated September 30 confirmed that Pike had not been pronounced dead and was being transported to a hospital for emergency medical care.
The state has since faced questions about how the exє𝔠uti☉n was carried out. Governor Bill Lee ordered a review and halted further scheduled executions while the incident is examined.
ANOTHER LEGAL BATTLE: THE LEFTOVER exє𝔠uti☉n DRUGS
The failed exє𝔠uti☉n has also sparked a separate legal dispute.
Pike’s attorneys want access to the remaining pentobarbital used during the September attempt so independent experts can examine and test it.
They argue that the drug’s labeling, storage, transportation, preparation and expiration information could help establish why the exє𝔠uti☉n failed.
But Tennessee officials have asked a judge to block the legal team from inspecting or testing the remaining drug.
In a court filing reported by the Associated Press and CBS News on November 10, state attorneys argued that access to the vials and their labels could expose the identity of the state’s confidential exє𝔠uti☉n-drug supplier.
Pike’s attorney Luke Ihnen has said that revealing the supplier’s identity is not the goal. He argues that examining the drug is necessary to understand what happened during the failed exє𝔠uti☉n.
The dispute places the state’s interest in protecting its supplier against Pike’s effort to investigate the circumstances of an exє𝔠uti☉n that left her seriously injured.
THREE DECADES LATER, THE EVIDENCE REMAINS
There is another deeply personal part of this story.
For years, the court clerk’s office also retained Slemmer’s skull and the fragment recovered from Pike’s jacket. According to the report, those remains were eventually returned to Slemmer’s mother, May Martinez, so she could finally have her daughter’s remains together.
Today, the clothing, weapons and other exhibits remain preserved in Knox County.
For the family of Colleen Slemmer, the passage of more than three decades has not erased the loss. For the courts, the evidence remains an enduring record of the crime.
And for Christa Pike, the failed September exє𝔠uti☉n has opened a new chapter of legal proceedings — one that is now focused on the state’s exє𝔠uti☉n procedures and the evidence that may explain what went wrong.
The 1995 murder and the 2026 exє𝔠uti☉n controversy are separate chapters, but both continue to bring the case back into public view.
More than three decades later, the evidence remains locked away — and the legal questions surrounding Christa Pike are far from over.