The chart that put one nurse in every shaded box is the evidence statisticians say a first-year student could dismantle

The image that did as much as any clinical opinion to fix Lucy Letby in the public mind was not a scan or a laboratory printout. It was a grid. Across a run of collapses and deaths at the Countess of Chester between 2015 and 2016, her row was shaded every time and almost nobody else’s was. Prosecutors treated it as the constant: she was there. Statisticians who later examined the grid have called it something else. Jane Hutton, professor of medical statistics at the University of Warwick, has described the material as a pile of broken crockery that cannot hold water however high it is stacked. John O’Quigley, an honorary professor of statistical science at University College London, has compared the reasoning to the lottery fallacy: the chance of a particular ticket winning is tiny, so the winner must have cheated. Peter Green, emeritus professor at the University of Bristol and a former president of the Royal Statistical Society, has said the chart is a classic misuse, and has noted the unsettling echo of Sally Clark, whose convictions for 𝘬iᩚlling her sons were later quashed after flawed statistics were exposed. The technical objection is selection, not arithmetic.

The events on the chart were not every dєatᩚh or collapse on the unit. They were the events that became the case. Collapses when Letby was not on duty were left off. Once the rows are chosen because she was present, her column fills by construction. The chart then proves only that she was present at the events selected because she was present. Private Eye’s medical columnist Phil Hammond has reported that dozens of other deaths or non-fatal collapses in the relevant period never appeared, including deaths for which she was not on duty and was never charged. A separate modelling exercise by Peter Elston, a fellow of the Royal Statistical Society, suggested that a small shift toward smaller and more premature babies could produce a spike in expected deaths that looks, on a crude plot, like foul play. A Royal College review had already noted that the unit was taking more premature and low-weight infants in those years. Police and prosecutors have answered that the grid was one brick in a wall, not the wall.

They say clinical evidence, notes, insulin results and colleague testimony carried the case, and that a statistician was considered and not relied upon. Hutton’s reply is that doctors with no statistical training were allowed to give statistical opinions, and that the failure to test the roster properly is exactly how medical-murder cases go wrong. The Royal Statistical Society has stopped short of declaring the verdict unsafe. It has said the form of argument used is the kind its own guidance, written after Sally Clark, warns courts against. That distinction matters. A bad chart does not free a defendant. It does mean a picture that looked like certainty to a jury may have been a tautology. The Criminal Cases Review Commission is the body that now has to decide whether that objection, joined to the medical disputes, creates a real possibility that the Court of Appeal would not uphold the convictions. The families of the babies have lived for years with a verdict. The statisticians are asking whether the verdict was partly a picture.

Related Posts

Heart-pounding moment hero California cops rescue teen from flaming car after train collision

Dramatic body-camera footage captured the moment police in San Bernardino County pulled a teen from a burning car that overturned after colliding with a train.

Officers with the Colton Police Departm…

Chaotic ICE arrest caught on video as protesters confront agents outside California police station

Federal immigration agents broke a car window and took a man into custody Friday morning outside the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station, where protesters filmed the arrest and several people repor…

Frightening moment young hiker plunges 40 feet from Bay Area trail

A young hiker took a terrifying tumble off a Berkeley trail — requiring a daring helicopter rescue to haul the injured youngster out of the rugged terrain.

The juvenile suffered a back injury in the …

3.3-magnitude earthquake strikes off LA coast

A preliminary 3.3-magnitude earthquake struck off the coast of Los Angeles Saturday morning.

The quake hit off the coast of San Pedro around a.m. at a depth of about 7 miles, according to the US Geol…

Mayor of major California city issues dire weather warning to Thanksgiving travelers: ‘Never seen before in recorded history’

San Francisco residents may not have seen the worst of extreme flooding that has stranded drivers and inundated the Bay Area the past few days — and now Mayor Daniel Lurie is sounding the alarm bells….

Wild moment beach ‘waterfall’ floods legendary SoCal surf spot as El Niño wreaks havoc

Wild storms overwhelmed an iconic Southern California surf spot and turned a beachfront staircase into a roaring “waterfall” pouring straight into the Pacific Ocean.

A video posted Thursday as storms…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *