Leaked Lawsuit Reveals Disturbing New Allegations in Noah Presgrove Case as Family Claims Teen Was Targeted Before His dєatᩚh

Nearly three years after 19-year-old Noah Presgrove was found dead beside a remote Oklahoma highway, a leaked court filing has brought a disturbing new development to the case, alleging that threats were made against him before he was attacked and pursued in an off-road vehicle.

The allegations appear in an amended complaint filed as part of a wrongful-dєatᩚh lawsuit brought by Presgrove’s family. The document reportedly describes a possible sequence of events leading up to his dєatᩚh, but the claims have not been proven in court.

Presgrove was found dead along U.S. Highway 81 near Terral, Oklahoma, on September 4, 2023. He had attended a birthday party over Labor Day weekend at a property roughly a mile from where his body was discovered.

He was found wearing only his shoes. An autopsy determined that he died from multiple blunt-force injuries, including severe trauma to his head and upper body. However, the medical examiner classified the manner of dєatᩚh as undetermined, meaning investigators could not establish whether it was a homicide, accident or another type of dєatᩚh.

New filing alleges threats before the fatal night

According to the first page of the amended complaint obtained by the Daily Mail, party host Avery Jo Combs allegedly made one or more statements about harming or 𝘬iᩚlling Presgrove on the morning before his dєatᩚh.

The filing further alleges that people at the gathering provided the teenager with alcohol beyond the point of intoxication, that multiple individuals attacked him, and that people pursued him in a side-by-side off-road vehicle before his body was discovered near the highway.

The leaked page does not identify all those allegedly involved in the attack or provide the full evidence supporting the claims.

One reported account from a partygoer described an earlier exchange in which Combs allegedly made a threatening remark after Presgrove had fallen asleep near another attendee. The significance of that conversation, and whether it was connected to the events that followed, has not been established.

Combs had previously denied allegations made against her in the original lawsuit. The Daily Mail reported that it sought a response from her attorneys regarding the new claims.

Three more people reportedly named in the lawsuit

The amended complaint reportedly adds three defendants: Brylan Sweat, Jasmine Millan and truck driver Christopher Payette.

Sweat appeared in what has been described as the last known video of Presgrove alive. Recorded at approximately 1:42 a.m. on September 4, the footage showed Presgrove repeatedly daring Sweat to slap him across the face. Sweat eventually gave him a light tap before running away.

Millan reportedly posted a Snapchat selfie at 3:41 a.m. with the caption, “well, Noah’s missing.” The timing has attracted attention because Presgrove’s body was discovered later that morning.

Payette was reportedly driving along Highway 81 shortly before another motorist called 911 about the body.

The leaked page does not explain the specific allegations against each newly named defendant. Being included in a civil lawsuit does not establish that someone committed a crime or was responsible for Presgrove’s dєatᩚh.

The filing also reportedly removes Caleb Newton, the father of Presgrove’s friend Jack Newton, from the list of defendants. Caleb told the Daily Mail that he had been removed but said he had not been given an explanation.

Conflicting accounts continue to cloud the investigation

The circumstances surrounding Presgrove’s final hours have remained unclear since his dєatᩚh.

Accounts gathered from people who attended the gathering describe an ATV accident earlier that night. Presgrove reportedly returned to the property afterward, showered and changed clothes. He was later said to have become upset following an argument and left the gathering.

However, witness accounts have differed over the timeline and what happened after he disappeared.

A Snapchat post reporting him missing appeared at 3:41 a.m. His body was discovered beside Highway 81 several hours later, prompting questions about how he sustained his injuries and ended up on the roadside.

The Oklahoma Highway Patrol previously stated that it was not investigating his dєatᩚh as a murder, although the investigation remained open. No criminal murder charges have been announced in connection with the case.

Family turns to civil court for answers

Presgrove’s family filed a wrongful-dєatᩚh lawsuit in 2025 against people they believe were connected to the events leading to his dєatᩚh. The original complaint alleged that he was beaten by one or more defendants and that people at the gathering had provided alcohol to underage and intoxicated attendees.

The defendants named in the original lawsuit denied liability in their court responses.

The family has also sought access to investigative records held by Oklahoma authorities. In February 2026, a judge ordered the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation to provide records for use in the civil proceedings, subject to restrictions on who could access and disclose them.

In October 2026, the family sought permission to have its amended petition filed publicly after information from the document had already circulated online. The full amended complaint had not been publicly released in the reporting reviewed.

For the family, the civil case represents another effort to uncover what happened during the final hours of Noah’s life.

The leaked allegations have raised fresh questions about the birthday gathering, the people who were there and the events that preceded the discovery of his body. But until the claims are examined through the legal process and supported by evidence, they remain allegations.

More than three years after the teenager’s dєatᩚh, the central mystery remains unresolved: what happened to Noah Presgrove, and who, if anyone, was responsible?

Source link: DAILYMAIL