BREAKING: SUSAN SMITH DENIED PAROLE AGAIN — EX-HUSBAND DAVID SMITH DELIVERS EMOTIONAL PLEA 32 YEARS AFTER THEIR SONS’ DEATHS
More than three decades after one of America’s most disturbing child-murder cases shocked the nation, Susan Smith has been denied parole for a second time. Her former husband, David Smith, returned to the parole hearing to speak for the two young boys who can no longer speak for themselves.
Susan Smith, now 55, will remain behind bars after a South Carolina parole board unanimously rejected her latest request for release on Thursday, November 19, 2026.
The decision came 32 years after the deaths of her two young sons, Michael and Alex, whose case became one of the most widely publicized criminal investigations in American history.
Smith is serving a life sentence for the 1994 murders of her children. She previously appeared before the parole board in November 2024, when her first request for release was also unanimously denied.
Now, after another emotional hearing, the board has reached the same conclusion.
Her next opportunity to seek parole will come in 2028.
THE CASE THAT SHOCKED AMERICA
In October 1994, Susan Smith reported that a Black man had carjacked her vehicle in Union County, South Carolina, with her two children still inside.
Her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, were believed to have been abducted.
For nine days, the story dominated national headlines. Smith appeared on television, making emotional appeals for the safe return of her children. Her then-husband, David Smith, also publicly pleaded for information that could help find the boys.
But investigators eventually uncovered the truth.
Smith confessed that she had allowed her car to roll into John D. Long Lake with both children strapped into their car seats.
The boys drowned.
Her false account of a carjacking had sent investigators and the public searching for an imaginary suspect while the children were already dead.
In July 1995, a jury convicted Smith of two counts of murder. She was sentenced to life in prison after the jury chose not to impose the dєatᩚh penalty.
Under South Carolina law at the time, she became eligible to request parole after serving 30 years.
DAVID SMITH RETURNS TO THE PAROLE BOARD
One of the most emotional moments of the November 19 hearing came when David Smith addressed the board.
More than 30 years after burying his sons, he returned to Columbia, South Carolina, determined to oppose his former wife’s release.
He wore a photograph of Michael and Alex pinned over his heart — the same image he had carried during the original trial and her first parole hearing.
David explained that although 32 years had passed, the loss remained painfully immediate.
He told the board that he was there to represent his sons because they could no longer speak for themselves.
In his testimony, he made clear that he believed their deaths were deliberate.
“She took away one of the greatest gifts God gives us — life. She did that deliberately. It wasn’t an accident, it wasn’t a mistake. She did it deliberately,” David told the board.
He also expressed the emotional difficulty of having to return to the hearing every two years to relive the tᩚraɢedy.
David was accompanied by members of his family, including his wife, Tiffany, and daughter, Savannah.
Their message was that releasing Susan Smith would be an injustice to Michael and Alex.
SUSAN SMITH APOLOGIZES AND ASKS FOR ANOTHER CHANCE
Appearing virtually from prison, Susan Smith addressed the parole board herself.
She acknowledged that her sons were innocent children who did not deserve what happened to them.
She expressed remorse for their deaths and apologized to David and others affected by her actions.
During the hearing, Smith said she was no longer the same person she had been 32 years earlier.
“I know that David didn’t get to see Michael and Alex grow up. You didn’t get to see him ride a bike or go to school. And I’m really, really sorry for that,” she told the board.
She also said she would go back and change what happened if she could.
Her attorney, Tommy Thomas, argued that Smith had experienced serious mєntal-health struggles around the time of the killings.
Her defense also presented arguments about her treatment, personal development and the possibility that she would pose a low risk if released.
A psychologist testified about improvements in her mєntal-health condition.
Smith asked the board for an opportunity to leave prison and contribute positively to society.
However, her request was rejected.
WHY THE PAROLE BOARD SAID NO
The hearing included arguments from both sides.
Smith’s defense emphasized her mєntal-health history, treatment and claimed rehabilitation during decades behind bars.
On the other side, prosecutors urged the board to consider the seriousness of the crimes, the impact on the victims’ family and the continuing consequences of her actions.
Former prosecutor Tommy Pope, who was involved in the original case, also spoke against her release.
Prosecutors have long argued that Smith killed her children because she wanted to pursue a new relationship and believed her sons stood in the way of that future.
Her defense has pointed to her mєntal-health struggles as an important part of understanding the events of 1994.
Ultimately, the parole board voted unanimously to deny her release.
The decision means Smith will continue serving her life sentence at Leath Correctional Institution in South Carolina.
A SECOND REJECTION — AND ANOTHER HEARING IN 2028
This was the second time Susan Smith had asked the South Carolina parole board to release her.
Her first hearing took place in November 2024, when David Smith also appeared to oppose her release.
The board rejected that request unanimously.
Under the applicable parole schedule, Smith can apply again after another two years.
Her next opportunity is expected in November 2028.
For David and his family, that means the painful process of revisiting the case may not be over.
He has previously said he intends to attend every parole hearing and continue speaking on behalf of his sons.
32 YEARS LATER, A FATHER STILL REMEMBERS HIS BOYS
The Susan Smith case remains a painful chapter in American criminal history, not only because of the crime itself but also because of the nine days during which the nation believed two missing children might still be found alive.
Michael and Alex never had the opportunity to grow up, attend school, ride bicycles as older children or build families of their own.
Their father has spent more than three decades living with that loss.
At Thursday’s hearing, David once again reminded the board that the passage of time does not erase what happened.
The unanimous decision means Susan Smith will remain in prison for at least another two years before she can seek parole again.
For David Smith, the fight was never simply about his former wife.
It was about remembering Michael and Alex — two little boys whose lives ended far too soon.
Thirty-two years have passed. The courtroom proceedings are long over, but for their father, the memory of his sons remains as powerful as ever.